item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in Te Ata o Tū The Shadow of Tūmatauenga: The New Zealand Wars Collections of Te Papa (Te Papa Press, 2024) on pages 358-359.
This extract was authored by Rebecca Rice.
By the early twentieth century the New Zealand Wars were becoming crucial to the ‘colonists’ quest to identify a history for themselves in their new home’.1 In the hands of historians like James Cowan, the wars served to underpin a new myth of race relations in which the conflict became formative, rather than destructive.
For Cowan, the New Zealand Wars were New Zealand’s frontier, and the mutual respect forged through interactions on the battlefield served to unite, rather than separate, Māori and Pākehā.2 He wanted Pākehā to remember their own wars, their own sacrifices on this soil, rather than forge an identity based on participation in global conflicts, such as the First World War.
With this shift in attitude, a craze for monument-building swept the country in the first decades of the twentieth century.3 At least 20 monuments to the New Zealand Wars were erected between 1907 and 1918,4 among them the Marsland Hill monument in New Plymouth, erected in 1909 to the memory of imperial and colonial soldiers who had fallen in the New Zealand Wars. A plot of land on the town-facing side of Marsland Hill had been granted for this purpose by Governor Grey in 1864,5 and a reserve created in 1869.6 Funds were also raised at this time, augmented by a performance by the 57th Regiment band, but the monument was not built.7
Efforts to erect a monument were revived in 1906 by Captain FJ Mace, when the Marsland Hill Memorial Committee was established to seek support and subscriptions towards a monument. Over a five-year period, funds were acquired and designs approved, and the statue was finally unveiled in 1909. Its final form consisted of an elaborate base, topped by a soldier modelled on George Messenger (the brother of the designer, Frank Messenger) and carved from Carrara marble in Italy.
In 1909 a Graves Committee was established to search out and tend to the graves of New Zealand Wars veterans. In the hands of the committee’s secretary, the formidable Edith Statham,8 the project soon evolved from recovering and renovating soldiers’ graves to seeking government funding to erect memorials throughout the North Island. Statham’s efforts were inspired by imperialism, and the hope that these projects would inculcate the ‘spirit of patriotism among our young people’.9
The majority of the monuments erected were to imperial and colonial soldiers; enemy Māori were memorialised only if they were ‘gallant and chivalrous’.10 Privileging Pākehā history and memory, these monuments are expressions of power: indicators of who, at that moment in time, got to choose what history was remembered and how it would be publicly memorialised.
Toward the end of the twentieth century, the power dynamics shifted, and such monuments increasingly became sites of protest. On Waitangi Day 1991, the figure on top of the Marsland memorial was smashed and toppled by protesters, and the monument defaced. The plinth remains empty to this day.
1 Kynan Gentry, History, Heritage and Colonialism: Historical consciousness, Britishness, and cultural identity in New Zealand, 1870–1940 (Manchester University Press, Manchester, 2015), p. 94.
2 Ibid., p. 110.
3 On Cowan’s research and writing process, see Chris Hilliard, ‘James Cowan and the Frontiers of New Zealand History’, New Zealand Journal of History, vol. 31, no. 2 (October 1997), pp. 219–33.
4 Gentry, History, Heritage and Colonialism, p. 99.
5 ‘Waikato War’, New Zealander, 27 February 1864, p. 6.
6 ‘Province of Taranaki’, Taranaki Herald, 26 June 1869, p. 5.
7 ‘Taranaki’, Otago Daily Times, 4 March 1864, p. 6.
8 Jock Phillips, ‘Statham, Edith Mary’, Dictionary of New Zealand Biography [1996], Te Ara – the Encyclopedia of New Zealand (teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/3s32/statham-edith-mary, accessed 6 January 2021).
9 Edith Statham, quoted in Jock Phillips, To the Memory: New Zealand’s war memorials (Potton & Burton, Nelson, 2016), p. 36.
10 Phillips, To the Memory, 2016, p. 44.