item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 Years of Photography in Aotearoa (Te Papa Press, 2025) on page 234.
‘In New Zealand the light is fairly hard, and soft, misty effects are rare,’ wrote the New Zealand correspondent to Photograms of the Year, the Reverend HO Fenton, in 1923. ‘There is scarcely any architecture that can be used pictorially. On the other hand the native bush has a charm all of its own. . .The New Zealander is too apt to try to copy English landscape, and fails to realise that he has a wealth of indigenous material all around him.’1 George Chance sold vast numbers of prints, riding on the public’s familiarity with his work through its publication in magazines such as the Weekly News, Brett’s Christmas Annual and the Mirror. But this particular photograph is quite rare today, suggesting it was less popular with audiences in its time, either because it was insufficiently nostalgic, too wild, or too much New Zealand. By rejecting the visual aesthetic of the English countryside, Chance may have been responding to Fenton’s challenge.
1 HO Fenton, ‘New Zealand’, Photograms of the year, 1921, p.25.