item details
Overview
Shadows of death seems an improbable photograph to have been made in New Zealand in 1940. Its construction of a formally ambiguous image from a sharply focused everyday scene suggests the New Photography of Europe in the 1920s and 1930s rather than the soft-focused and sentimental framework of pictorialism then prevailing in New Zealand photography. Indeed, it was made by a newly arrived Austrian immigrant.
Richard Sharell was an accomplished amateur photographer in a variety of modes before he left Europe, with inclusion in the 1934 Third International Photo Exhibition in Vienna already to his credit. In New Zealand he concentrated on photographing the country’s fauna, and eventually published two books on natural history, The tuatara, lizards and frogs of New Zealand, 1966, and New Zealand insects and their story, 1971. Sharell had been a biology as well as an art and craft teacher in Austria, and considered that art and science could be usefully combined because ‘only a harmonious union of their spheres in life and work [can] give a full appreciation of the wonders of nature’.1 His early New Zealand works, and a handful of images in the later books, recall the ‘design in nature’ theme of 1920s German photographers such as Karl Blossfeldt and Albert Renger-Patzsch, with their close-ups of natural forms that revealed nature in ways not seen before.
Dramatic, oblique shadows are also commonplace in Sharell’s earlier images of flora and fauna, creating a doubling of forms with sometimes fantastical and sinister results. In a 1940 photograph of a stick insect titled Harmless creature and its fearful shadows (Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa), for example, the shadow looms above the insect like a horror-movie cliché. And here, in this image of flypaper strips against weatherboards, the shadows of dead or dying flies look threatening and nightmarish. In fact, predation and death in the insect world is a theme that runs through several photographs Sharell made in the early 1940s. A title like Shadows of death raises the question whether these images are consciously or unconsciously symbolic, given the background of war and Sharell’s personal experience of several months’ incarceration in Dachau before becoming a refugee of Nazism.
Athol McCredie
This essay appears in Art at Te Papa, (Te Papa Press, 2009)
1. Richard Sharell, The tuatara, lizards and frogs of New Zealand, Collins, London, 1966, p. 11.
This extract originally appeared in New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 Years of Photography in Aotearoa (Te Papa Press, 2025) on page 242.
Richard Sharell arrived in New Zealand in 1940 as a Jewish–Austrian refugee from Nazism. An accomplished photographer, he had been a teacher of biology and arts. Sharell’s photographs from the 1930s often sit on the sometimes-blurry line between pictorialism and modernism. His images of patterns in nature, for example, could easily slide into either camp. But there is little overtly pictorialist about his image of strips of flypaper hanging down the weatherboards of a New Zealand house. This photograph is about formal ambiguity, where the shadows carry as much meaning and visual weight as the objects projecting them. The black specks of dead or dying flies on the flypaper are magnified in the shadows to look like a nightmarish army lined up on a hilltop horizon. Unlike another European exile, Frank Hofmann, Sharell did not participate in the exhibitions and competitions of New Zealand’s camera club scene. He focused his energies on photographing nature, publishing an illustrated book on New Zealand’s tuatara, lizards and frogs, and another on the country’s insects.