item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 Years of Photography in Aotearoa (Te Papa Press, 2025) on page 225.
HE Gaze’s photograph of a woman poling a punt at the margin of a still lake recalls PH Emerson’s images of English peasant life in the tidal areas of East Anglia. In Naturalistic Photography for Students of the Art (1889), one of the early texts on photography as art, Emerson had suggested that nature and art were interwoven. His photographs of people wresting a hard life from the fields and waterways proposed an alternative to the era’s often-squalid city life: something that was idyllic, true and real. In this evening-light scene, Gaze too suggests the honesty, romance and, above all, timelessness of a life close to nature. Emerson came in for criticism when it became known that some of his ‘peasants’ were in fact friends who had dressed up for the role. Gaze’s woman is obviously not a peasant either — she wears a city dress, stockings and smart shoes. For both photographers, the conveyed truth of the picture was more important than the literal truth of how it was taken.