item details
Overview
This essay originally appeared in New Zealand Art at Te Papa (Te Papa Press, 2018).
Janet Bayly’s work is often intimate and private, a conscious reworking of the past in the present. On a sideboard in her grandparents’ house, photographs of her grandfather and parents are lovingly reunited in a devotional tableau. In this seemingly gothic take on family history, the artist creates a time capsule as she recontextualises, rearranges and reproduces two photographs of two generations of her family.
This image is, in part, about the orderly passage of time and family history, one generation preceding another, giving us the symbolically fixed poles — grandparents, mother, father — that we use to understand ourselves. But this is not just a simple family history lesson. Our eyes move between the young man on the left, Bayly’s grandfather, looking dapper in a formal suit, to the young couple in formal attire on a slatted wooden bench. Her mother was twenty-one; her father was in his late twenties; they were newly married. The image of her grandfather as a young man was taken just after his service in the First World War. There is an equivalence of age across generations — a marking of youth — and Bayly herself was twenty-five when she made this image. Bayly says she likes to yoke ‘past, present, and future’ together, and here we are reminded of the hopes that young people have and of the inevitable fragility of all lives.
For Bayly, the notion of the photograph as icon was an important one. What held the artist’s interest is photography’s capacity to freeze time to produce a fragmentary narrative of family history. But Bayly resists full disclosure here; she hovers out of sight while controlling the family narrative through juxtaposition. This kind of memory-work is necessarily ambiguous. ‘I photographed the photographs — to me they are freighted — very loaded. The significance to me — it’s like looking at a visual novel about your family mysteries.’1
This intimate private portrait of family is a private relic, as well as having universal significance. The image stands for all families and for their absence. We want to know who they were, and what clues they might offer to the meaning of our own lives — family matters.
Sandy Callister
1 Janet Bayly, personal communication with Sandy Callister, 15 October 2017.