item details
Unknown; photography studio; circa 1860
Overview
This extract originally appeared in Te Ata o Tū The Shadow of Tūmatauenga: The New Zealand Wars Collections of Te Papa (Te Papa Press, 2024) on page 337.
This extract was authored by Rebecca Rice.
In 1900, William Francis Gordon received in the post a glass-plate positive of William Odgers (1834–1873), the first recipient of the Victoria Cross during the New Zealand Wars.1 It was sent by Captain Gassiot and was apparently the only photograph ever taken of Odgers, made in Queen Street shortly after the battle at Waireka on 28 March 1860,2 at which Odgers’ ‘conspicuous gallantry . . . having been the first to enter it [the pā] under a heavy fire, and having assisted in hauling down the enemy’s colours’ was noted.3
Newspapers reported that the glass positive ‘came to hand through the post broken into pieces but fortunately the head and shoulder region was still intact’.4 Gordon photographed the surviving features and framed Odgers’ bust in a drawn golden braid set upon the background of a Union Jack flag, the flagpole just visible on the left-hand side. The result is a remarkable work of art that simultaneously celebrates the imperial forces and records the act for which Odgers was awarded the VC.
Gordon wasn’t the only one to doctor the past, however. According to recent historians, the battle at Waireka was a ‘classic example of a paper victory’, and its details were grossly exaggerated.5
1 This was most likely an ambrotype — a popular process for portraits in New Zealand in the mid-1850s. Ambrotypes were made on glass plates that had been coated with collodion, then dipped into silver nitrate to make a light-sensitive surface.
2 ‘Battle of Waireka’, Taranaki Herald, 28 March 1933, Te Papa Archives, CA162/1/4/6.
3 London Gazette, cited in Denis Fairfax, ‘Odgers, William’, Dictionary of New Zealand Biography [1990], Te Ara – the Encyclopedia of New Zealand (teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/1o3/odgers-william, accessed 27 March 2017).
4 ‘Battle of Waireka’, Taranaki Herald.
5 See Belich, The New Zealand Wars, pp. 84–88.