item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in Te Ata o Tū The Shadow of Tūmatauenga: The New Zealand Wars Collections of Te Papa (Te Papa Press, 2024) on pages 264-265.
This extract was authored by Matiu Baker, Michael Fitzgerald and Katie Cooper.
John Handley (1841–1916) was a well-known Whanganui settler, farmer and soldier. His parents, John and Martha, had a farm at Ōkehu near Nukumaru, not far from Tītokowaru’s great fortress of Taurangaika. In 1868, a paddock near the farm’s woolshed was the site of one of the most notorious atrocities of the New Zealand Wars.
In late 1868, Handley was a sergeant in a local Volunteer unit, the Kai Iwi Cavalry, whose lieutenant in command was fellow farmer and budding politician John Bryce. Handley’s brother William was running the farm when, on 18 November, the farmhouse was burned down by Tītokowaru’s forces, and the family took shelter in Whanganui.1 On 27 November, men of the unit who were on patrol attacked several Māori boys they encountered near the woolshed. The boys, all under the age of 13, had gone out from Taurangaika to catch pigs and turkeys. Two were killed by sabre slashes and revolver shots, others were wounded.2 John Handley later testified that he had galloped off in pursuit of the boys, but got stuck at a fence so did not ‘get among them’ until one boy had already been killed. He did not see the other victim die.3
In 1883, there was a famous libel case when John Bryce, Minister of Native Affairs from 1879 to 1884 and leader of the invasion of Parihaka in 1881, took legal action against the historian John Rusden for stating that his men had cut down Māori women and children ‘gleefully and with ease’.4 Bryce was eventually awarded £5000 in damages on the grounds that Rusden falsely stated the troopers had killed or wounded women.5
After the wars, Handley re-established himself as a farmer and was active in the area’s political and social life. His obituary claimed that he was ‘held in the highest esteem by both races, the Natives bestowing upon him the complimentary name “Purakau”. He interested himself in the collection of Maori curios, and a fine collection in the local Museum is a tribute to his labours.’6 Handley also dealt with the Colonial Museum, and this photograph of him posing with taonga was probably taken in 1905, when the museum purchased 252 taonga from his collection . . .7
Beyond his glowing obituary, however, Handley appears to have had a more complicated relationship with Māori. In 1896 he took a case against Toko Reihana of Kai Iwi in a ‘claim for a valuable curio’, a hoeroa that belonged to Reihana and which was formerly associated with his kinsman Kīngi Tāwhiao.8
In 1902, Ropiha Rangihaukori (Ngā Rauru) of Ōpunake was said to have written a scathing letter, published in the Wanganui Herald, that denounced Handley as a friend of Ngā Rauru and which said he had failed to uphold the values and attributes of their former rangatira, Pūrākau, whose name he had taken for himself. The letter instructed Handley not to visit their kāinga any more.9
Characters like Handley highlight some of the complexities of Pākehā collecting in the second half of the nineteenth century, especially following the land confiscations that largely marginalised Māori from Pākehā society and excluded them from the economy, leaving them vulnerable to settlers who leveraged taonga and land from them.
1 Belich, I Shall Not Die, p. 200; ‘More Settlers’ Houses Burnt by the Rebels’, Colonist, 4 December 1868, p. 6.
2 ‘Reminiscences of the Maori War’, Wanganui Herald, 29 July 1902, p. 2.
3 Testimony of John Handley, 12 May 1885, Bryce v. Rusden: in the High Court of Justice, Queen’s Bench Division, Royal Courts of Justice, Thursday, 4th March, 1886, before Baron Huddleston and a special jury (Waterlow Bros. & Layton, Printers, London, 1886), p. 530-531; Laraine Sole, The Way We Were: The Settlement of Maxwell and Waitotara, 1850-1930 (Waverley-Aotea Rotary Club, Waverley, 1990).
4 George W Rusden, History of New Zealand, vol. 2 (Chapman & Hall, London, 1883), pp. 504–5. See also Belich, I Shall Not Die, chapter 10.
5 The amount paid was later reduced to just over half this amount. See O’Malley, The New Zealand Wars, p. 204.
6 ‘Obituary, Mr. John Handley’, Wanganui Chronicle, 2 September 1916, p. 4.
7 ‘J. Handley collection of Maori Antiquities’, 1905-1908, correspondence file, Te Papa Archives, MU412/001/0014.
8 ‘John Handley v. Toko Reihana. A claim for a valuable curio’, Wanganui Chronicle, 7 October 1896, p. 3.
9 ‘Reply to Mr John Handley’, Wanganui Herald, 1 September 1902, p. 2.