item details
Overview
During his lifetime, Rembrandt's extraordinary skills as a printmaker were the main source of his international fame. Unlike his oil paintings, prints travelled light and were relatively cheap. For this reason, they soon became very popular with collectors not only within, but also beyond the borders of the Netherlands, and it also explains why, three centuries later, they were affordable for Wellington collector and philanthropist Sir John Ilott, who presented 37 Rembrandt prints to the National Art Gallery between 1952 and 1969.
In 1654, the date of this etching, Rembrandt was in his late 40s and no longer the flavour of the month in Dutch painting but still famous and admired for his etching. His mistress Hendrickje Stoffels gave birth to an illegitimate daughter, Cornelia, and his finances were unravelling due to his extravagance. This could well be why he chose the stories of Christ's youth - certain sellers - as the subject of a series of prints. These comprised Christ returning from the Temple with his parents, The flight into Egypt: crossing a brook, The Virgin and Child with the cat and the snake, The adoration of the shepherds: with the lamp and The circumcision in the stable. This print is part of the series.
Despite their likely commercial motives, he endowed the stories with freshness and originality.
Gesturing excitedly and hardly able to sit still, the twelve-year old Jesus disputes with the Doctors in the Temple. The wise old men listen attentively, and their astonishment at such youthful wisdom is clear to read from their attitude and facial expressions. Rembrandt kept the composition light by using shadow sparsely and indicating the background with little more than a few rough contour lines.
References: New Hollstein Dutch 281, only state; Hollstein Dutch 64, only state.
See:
Minneapolis Institute of Art, https://collections.artsmia.org/art/57586/christ-disputing-with-the-doctors-rembrandt-harmensz-van-rijn
Rijksmuseum, https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/en/collection/RP-P-OB-125
Dr Mark Stocker Curator, Historical International Art August 2017