item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 Years of Photography in Aotearoa (Te Papa Press, 2025) on page 103.
The farmer, writer, naturalist and birdwatcher Herbert Guthrie-Smith is best known for his book Tutira: The story of a New Zealand sheep station (1921), a closely observed cultural and natural history of his Hawke’s Bay farm. Guthrie-Smith understood Tutira’s story to be typical of the impact of European settlement on the land, and came to doubt the wisdom of his own activities as a farmer; in his 1936 book, Sorrows and Joys of a New Zealand Naturalist, he called the loss of indigenous flora and fauna due to land clearances a ‘sad, bad, mad, incomprehensible business’.1 This photograph of the remains of a forest burnt down to create a farm reflects Guthrie-Smith’s deeply felt understanding of the ecological impact of farming. It provides a poignant counter to the many other photographs that extolled the taming and settling of the land.
1 Ronda Cooper, ‘Guthrie-Smith, William Herbert’, Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, first published in 1996. Te Ara—the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/3g27/guthrie-smith-william-herbert, accessed 28 October 2024.