item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in Te Ata o Tū The Shadow of Tūmatauenga: The New Zealand Wars Collections of Te Papa (Te Papa Press, 2024) on pages 383-384.
This extract was authored by Rebecca Rice.
The Western tradition of monument-making is based on the assumption that objects can act as prompts to memory, to help us remember notable individuals or events. But in recent decades it has become increasingly obvious that the decisions about who or what is remembered (or, conversely, who or what is forgotten) are deliberate, highly regulated and most often made by white men to commemorate other white men and their achievements.
The implications of the biases of these collective ‘memory-making’ monuments were brought home to Michael Shepherd as Aotearoa New Zealand approached the sesquicentenary of the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi in 1990. Shepherd was aware of the irony (and basic untruth) of the national slogan ‘Huia Tuia Tui Tuia – One Country One People’,1 and, inspired by James Belich’s description of the ‘absurd’ battle at Koheroa, created the series Monuments. Shepherd described how he ‘had long had an interest in the New Zealand monument and decided that this vehicle could freeze time and yet, with the advent of the “post-colonial” language of 1990, the opportunity to lay graffiti across the top of it, was one I could not resist’.2
In the six works that make up the Monuments series, Shepherd challenges the harmonious sentiment of the sesquicentennial commemorations. In 1. Plans for a monument (actions speak loudest) he adds ‘The language of colonialism’ in brackets to the optimistic slogan, while also reminding us of the Victorian habit of claiming victories following indecisive events, writing under the inscription ‘Commemorating the Battle of Koheroa’, ‘We Won’. The works are monochromatic, executed in sepia-toned ink. The figures are awkwardly depicted, the landscapes minimally rendered, recalling the clumsy visual language of many memorials. Shepherd’s Monuments engender a cunning sleight of hand; his style, evoking an art of the past, acts as a foil to the critical postcolonial sentiment they contain.
1 Robyn Anderson and Keith Pickens, ‘Wellington District: Port Nicholson, Hutt Valley, Porirua, Rangitikei and Manawatu’, Working Paper, Waitangi Tribunal, Rangahaua Whanui Series, August 1996.
2 ‘Opening of the Supreme Court’, New Zealand Herald and Auckland Gazette, 2 March 1842, p. 3.