item details
Overview
This extract originally appeared in New Zealand Photography Collected: 175 Years of Photography in Aotearoa (Te Papa Press, 2025) on page 334.
Ben Cauchi photographs mysteries, or rather puzzles and illusions that are particularly photographic. In A subterfuge, he uses the nineteenth-century ambrotype process to return us to a time when photography was seen as magical — when what it was and wasn’t capable of were still unclear. In the 1870s, for example, it was widely accepted that spirit photography captured ghostly images of the dead, even when it became well known that the effect could easily be produced by double exposure. Whether or not Cauchi’s subject here is spectral, it is certainly ambiguous — a strange, semi-animate shape that looks like it was constructed from crumpled paper. Whatever it is makes no sense. The ambrotype’s limited tonal palette makes it difficult to pick out detail in the highlights, rendering them both luminous and indistinct. And a flaw in the glass plate during preparation or processing has left two enigmatic black ‘holes’ at the bottom right. They seem to undermine the image’s stability, like two parasitical worms about to eat up through it.